Affiliate links on our site may earn us commissions. Learn More.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy Policy.

arrow
Newsletter

Discover The Best Wellness Tips In Your Inbox

Subscribe to Health Reporter’s newsletter and get our health experts’ highlights and the latest news about healthy living.
The newsletters are spam-free and sent from our health experts and professionals.
sent

Thank You!

You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter!

How do we vet brands and products? Learn more.

Home arrow Nutrition arrow Weight Management arrow MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal: Which Is the Best Calorie Counter?

MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal: Which Is the Best Calorie Counter?

Wendy Lord, RD
Written by Wendy Lord, RD
Dr. Donika Vata
Fact checked by Donika Vata, MD
Last update: September 29, 2023
6 min read 368 Views 0 Reviews
clock 6 eye 368 comments 0

Calorie counter apps are useful tools for achieving your weight goals, but choosing the right one out of many can be tough. In this article, I uncover the differences between two leading options: MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal.

mynetdiary vs myfitnesspal

How do we vet brands and products? Learn more.

A digital calorie counter can be a valuable tool in maintaining dietary discipline. One effective approach to monitoring calorie consumption is to use one of the many weight loss apps available in the Android and iOS app stores.

Two of the most popular calorie tracker apps are MyNetDiary and MyFitnessPal. They share many of the same features for keeping track of your daily food intake, and both offer a free and a paid version so anyone can use them.

I put both apps to the test to uncover the similarities and differences between MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal so that you can choose the one that best fits your needs and budget.

MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal: Which Is Better?

Comparison Winner: MyFitnessPal
4.2
stars
4.0
stars
Brand
MyFitnessPal
MyNetDiary
Pros

Extensive food database

Calorie counter

Exercise diary

Detailed meal plans

Easy-to-follow workouts

Integrates with other health and fitness trackers

Free version

Available for iOS and Android devices

Extensive food database

User-friendly calorie counter

Exercise diary Personalized meal plans

Foods graded according to nutritional value

Support from online community monitored by registered dietitians

Available for iOS and Android devices

Cons

Large ads on the free version

The paid version can be expensive

Navigation is slow

The barcode scanner doesn’t recognize all foods

Ads on the free version

Macro tracking is only available on the premium version

Macronutrients are not calculated per meal

Virtual coach is generic and not backed by humans

After thoroughly researching MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal, I believe that MyFitnessPal comes out on top. The pros and cons of both calorie counting apps are listed in the table below.

What is MyNetDiary?

MyNetDiary logo
Our rating:
4.0
stars
  • Extensive database with over 1.25 million approved foods
  • User-friendly calorie counter
  • Foods graded according to nutritional value
  • Meal ideas and recipes
  • Tracks activity, water, blood glucose, and medicine
Learn More

MyNetDiary is a comprehensive and easy-to-use app to keep track of how many calories you eat. It includes an extensive database of foods that are graded according to the nutritional information available for each food item to guide you towards eating healthier weight loss foods.

The main feature is the calorie counter; however, the app offers fitness, water, blood glucose, and medication tracking. It can sync with fitness devices and other apps to simplify data entry and provide an overview of your progress.

Pros
  • checkmark
    Extensive food database
  • checkmark
    User-friendly food diary
  • checkmark
    Exercise, water, blood glucose, and medicine tracking
  • checkmark
    Calorie-specific meal plans
  • checkmark
    Extensive support from online community monitored by registered dietitians
  • checkmark
    Free version available
  • checkmark
    Available for iOS and Android devices
Cons
  • checkmark
    Adds on the free option
  • checkmark
    Macro tracking is only available on the paid version
  • checkmark
    Virtual coach is generic and not backed by humans

What is MyFitnessPal?

myfitnesspal logo
Our rating:
4.2
stars
  • Extensive database of foods
  • Detailed meal plans
  • Calorie counting
  • Exercise tracker
  • Easy-to-follow workouts
Learn More

MyFitnessPal is a popular and versatile calorie counter and fitness tracking app. The app offers personalized profiles, a barcode scanner to simplify calorie tracking, goal setting, and macro and micronutrient nutritional insights.

Your personal information is kept safe and used to establish your calorie budget to help you lose weight and boost your fitness. 

You are also encouraged to connect with friends to share your progress, improve your motivation, give encouragement, and provide accountability to each other. The extensive support offered by the MyFitnessPal community can help keep you on track.

Pros
  • checkmark
    Extensive database of foods
  • checkmark
    Intuitive calorie counter
  • checkmark
    Exercise tracking
  • checkmark
    Detailed meal plans with a personalized calorie budget
  • checkmark
    Integration with other health and fitness apps and trackers
  • checkmark
    Free version available
  • checkmark
    Available for iOS and Android devices
Cons
  • checkmark
    Large ads on the free option that interfere with the user experience
  • checkmark
    Paid premium version can be expensive
  • checkmark
    The barcode scanner doesn’t recognize all foods

MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal: Features

The best weight loss apps, like MyNetDiary and MyFitnessPal, share many useful features, such as those listed below: 

  • An extensive food database 
  • A barcode scanner, which scans the barcode on products to automatically log your calories and calculate the nutritional values of your diet
  • Weight tracking
  • Exercise tracking
  • Recording your daily water intake
  • Calculated calorie budget
  • An extensive collection of healthy recipes
  • Community and social features for added motivation, accountability, and support
  • Syncing with other health and fitness wearables and apps

When comparing MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal, it is clear that although they are both calorie counting apps, each offers other unique features that may make them more appealing to you. Let’s take a look at those for both products.

MyNetDiary:

  • Diabetes tracking: MyNetDiary allows people with diabetes to track medication and blood glucose levels via integration with their glucometer. It also provides glycemic index and glycemic load information for foods.
  • Food grading system: Foods are given a grade based on their calorie content and nutritional value so that you can focus on eating healthy weight-loss foods, not only focusing on calories.

MyFitnessPal:

  • Restaurant logging: MyFitnessPal allows you to log meals from popular restaurant chains, providing nutritional information for menu items.
  • Challenges and goals: MyFitnessPal offers various challenges and goal-setting features to help you stay motivated and engaged in your health and fitness journey.
  • Offline access: The app provides limited offline access, allowing you to log meals and activities when the internet is not available.

Benefits

Although both apps offer unique features, they also share similar benefits.

  • Weight loss: People who record calories and track their dietary intake have been shown to enjoy consistent and long-term weight loss.
  • Calorie requirements: The apps help you calculate your calorie budget.
  • Exercise tracker: Research suggests that it may increase your motivation to exercise, the enjoyment of your workout, your fitness level, and your health and well-being. 
  • Portion control: When you know the calorie content of the food you’re eating, it becomes easier to watch your portion sizes

Downsides

Calorie counting isn’t for everyone, and even the best weight loss apps share the following downsides:

  • A focus on calories rather than healthy meals, which may result in eating disorders
  • Not considering individual variations in factors such as metabolism and gut microbiome
  • Logging everything, which can be impractical and time-consuming
  • Lack of consideration regarding health conditions

As with certain features and benefits, there are specific downsides when it comes to MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal:

MyNetDiary:

  • Generic virtual health coach, making it impossible to get personalized advice 
  • No personal motivation features

MyFitnessPal:

  • Bugging barcode scanner, which may increase the time it takes to log your meals
  • Large ads on the free option, which affect the user experience

Pricing

MyNetDiary and MyFitnessPal both offer a free option of the app so that you can try it out before committing to the paid version. Of course, the premium version adds significant features to both calorie counters. 

MyNetDiary: A monthly payment of $6.50 gives you access to customized nutrient goals, comprehensive nutrient tracking, and personalized meal plans.

MyFitnessPal: For a monthly fee of $19.99 or an annual payment of $79.99, you get access to features such as barcode and meal scanning, macro tracking with personalized goals, and guided meal and workout plans. 

MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal vs. Alternatives

There are several alternative apps to MyFitnessPal and MyNetDiary that offer similar features, such as Weight Watchers (WW) and Perfect Body. See how other apps compare to MyNetDiary and MyFitnessPal in the table below.

Comparison Winner: DoFasting
4.7
stars
4.6
stars
4.4
stars
4.4
stars
4.3
stars
4.3
stars
4.3
stars
4.2
stars
4.2
stars
4.1
stars
4.1
stars
4.0
stars
3.9
stars
4.0
stars
Brand
DoFasting
Tuby
Lose It!
Perfect Body
Weight Watchers
Cronometer
Greatness
MyFitnessPal
Peloton
Noom
Fitbit
Lifesum
Happy Scale
MyNetDiary
Pros

Suitable for beginners and pros

Choice of 3 monthly pricing options

Easy navigation

100% science-based

No equipment needed

Workouts can be performed anywhere, at any time

Multiplayer option

Simple, user-friendly interface

Smart camera allows you to detect multiple foods at once

Connects with multiple apps and devices

Meal plans are designed by nutritionists

Ingredients for meals can be found easily in grocery stores

Web version available

Recommended by doctors

Programs are easy to follow

Expert coaches and members community provide support

Free version available

You can set your own macronutrient intake

Sync with a wide range of apps and devices

Created by experts in behavioral science

Habits can easily be fit into a busy schedule

Can choose your own goals and custom reminders

Extensive food database

Calorie counter

Exercise diary

Detailed meal plans

Easy-to-follow workouts

Integrates with other health and fitness trackers

Free version

Available for iOS and Android devices

No equipment needed

Workout from anywhere

Free to sign up

Doesn’t restrict any food groups

Teaches users why they are making changes

Can adjust your goals easily

Premium version offers a 90-day free trial

Encourages you to reach your step count with regular reminders

Integrates with many other apps

Suitable for a range of dietary requirements

Can be personalized to suit your preferences

Sync between all of your devices

Use with other popular apps, like Apple Health

Keeps your profile private with a passcode

Extensive food database

User-friendly calorie counter

Exercise diary Personalized meal plans

Foods graded according to nutritional value

Support from online community monitored by registered dietitians

Available for iOS and Android devices

Cons

No free trial offered

Premium features cost more

Smaller food database than other weight loss apps

Ads on the free version

Need a premium subscription to access more features

No free trial

Unsuitable for those who are pregnant or breastfeeding

Virtual or in-person workshops aren’t for everyone

App interface can be hard to navigate

The weight loss app itself isn’t run by physicians

Premium features only available on the Gold version

Users may choose the wrong macronutrient ratio for their goals

Requires a monthly subscription

Not compatible with smartwatches

Large ads on the free version

The paid version can be expensive

Navigation is slow

The barcode scanner doesn’t recognize all foods

Free app only offers a limited collection of classes

Memberships are quite pricey

Recommends that users weigh themselves daily

Relatively expensive

No custom meal plans

Requires a Fitbit tracker or smartwatch to work

Stats aren’t always 100% accurate

No personalized meal or training plans available

No personalized fitness programs

Users can add to the food database, so it may not be accurate

Only offers basic nutritional information

No fitness or nutritional information

Can only track weight loss

Ads on the free version

Macro tracking is only available on the premium version

Macronutrients are not calculated per meal

Virtual coach is generic and not backed by humans

How I Tested the Products

I tested calorie counter apps in the same way we at Health Reporter determine the best weight loss supplements. Therefore, when comparing MyNetDiary vs. MyFitnessPal, I examined the following criteria: 

Quality

The user experience is key in determining the quality of an application, and in this case, the accuracy of the food database must also be considered.

Effectiveness

The effectiveness score is based on user reviews. Many people find these apps useful for losing weight. However, how well they work depends on how frequently you use them and how accurately you record your food intake. 

Price

Whether you choose to use the free or premium version of MyNetDiary and MyFitnessPal depends on how much support you feel you need to achieve your goals. While the free versions are useful, the paid plans offer significantly more features.

Brand reputation

A reputable brand consistently delivers high-quality products. In the case of MyNetDiary and MyFitnessPal, both companies have ensured that you have access to an extensive food database providing accurate nutritional information.

FAQs 

What is the difference between MyNetDiary and MyNetDiary Pro?

The main difference between MyNetDiary and MyNetDiary Pro is more advanced macro and micronutrient tracking, which provides more nutritional information. You can also customize your goals and use the calorie counter offline with MyNetDiary Pro.

Is MyNetDiary good for weight loss?

Based on user reviews, MyNetDiary is good for weight loss. A scientific study also found that MyNetDiary and MyNetDiary Pro were good for promoting the behavior change required for losing weight.

Where can you get MyFitnessPal?

Find the app on the MyFitnessPal website.

Is MyFitnessPal accurate?

Research has found that MyFitnessPal is accurate for calculating your calorie intake, carbohydrates, protein, fat, sugar, and fiber.

A Word From Our RD

If you’re looking for a weight loss program to help you lose weight fast, calorie counter apps probably won’t get you the results you want. However, they can be beneficial if you find it useful to keep track of your calories while dieting.

Counting calories offers several benefits for people wanting to lose weight. However, there are numerous reasons why it doesn’t work for everyone. One of the biggest drawbacks is the focus on calories instead of healthy eating.

When studying the impact of calorie-based consumer education, scientists found that it is less effective for losing weight than teaching people about the type of food they should be eating.

On the other hand, people who track calories using weight loss apps have been shown to lose weight more successfully than those who don’t track their progress.

Whether you choose to keep a written food diary or make use of a calorie counter app, you must make sure that you have chosen the best diet for you. It must meet your nutritional requirements and fit into your lifestyle to improve your chances of success.

Conclusion

After comparing the features of MyNetDiary and MyFitnessPal, I think MyFitnessPal offers the most benefits with only a few inconsequential downsides. 

The choice is yours, though. Although the apps offer similar benefits and features, the calorie counter you choose to track your calorie intake must meet your requirements and your budget. 

Written by Wendy Lord, RD
Wendy is a Registered Dietitian with a passion for writing about nutrition, health, and medicine. Her aim is to translate the medical jargon to make information accessible to everyone so that they can make informed decisions about their health.
The article was fact checked by Donika Vata, MD
Was this article helpful?
check
Thank you! We received Your feedback
Wendy Lord, RD
Written by Wendy Lord, RD
Dr. Donika Vata
Fact checked by Donika Vata, MD
Last update: September 29, 2023
6 min read 368 Views 0 Reviews
0 Reviews

Leave a review

checked
Thank you for your comment!
We will review it as soon as possible.
HealthReporter
Review title
Missing required field
Rating: 0 to 10
Missing required field. Entered rating must be between 0 to 10
Entered rating must be between 0 to 10
Your Name
Missing required field
Your Comment
Missing required field

company-logo